Friday, July 20, 2012

Hope of Leadership amidst Hopelessness

Sharing my observation on the current status of leadership (or rather lack of it) in our society, I wrote in my FB status:
“Leaders, leaders and leaders everywhere...but not an inspiration to draw from!  Yes, there is leadership deficit.”
I was asked about what might be the cause of leadership deficit.  To which my reply:
“I appreciate your question the answer to which probably justifies writing a whole book. In essence, I believe our society and our organizations have not invested enough in developing leadership in our country. Leadership, unlike so-called 'leaders' of different shades and colors, does not grow out of nothing; it is the result of huge social and organizational investment, which has not been made on the scale that produces transformational, authentic and intentional leadership with the capability of making substantial changes. That said, I'd promptly add that the social and organizational conditions are, though, ripe for the emergence of high quality leadership. Our society needs to make more investment in leadership making.”
A comment was made that this probably reflects the failure in our education system, suggesting that Kathmandu University in particular has failed to produce leaders despite its reputation.  My humble submission:
“Yes, our education system is partially to blame for having failed to produce leadership in society that inspires and transforms people but leadership development in the society is a function of huge social investment.  Leadership deficit we are experiencing is the result of this lack of social investment. If Oxford or Harvard or any other universities have produced finest leadership in their societies and elsewhere, it’s not only because of the education they give in the universities but more significantly they enjoy the advantage in the societies they are embedded in of having the tradition of huge social investment in making leadership.

“I was referring in my status to the leadership on the larger social scale, and not to the functional leadership that lead people and systems towards making and meeting goals. As for functional leadership in the domains that KU specializes, my own assessment is that our graduates are showing tremendous potential for leading their respective domains in a way that has never happened in our organizations; and indeed they are already exercising quality leadership at the middle to just-below-the top levels. It is there for anyone to see.
“As for the leadership on a broader social and national context, one university, even with KU’s reputation and resolve, cannot shape leadership on its own, no matter how much we try, unless there is huge social investment for it. I’m not sure whether such an investment is forthcoming or not in future, but even if it does, development of the quality leadership on a broader social scale will take time. Two decades is not an adequate time frame for any university to produce social leadership, particularly in the absence of the kind of investment I talked about earlier.  KU’s first few batches of graduates have just entered their mid-career and mid-life.

“Watch it out, when they and their juniors get past this stage, they will definitely take charge of and change the systems they are responsible for in a way never before done. And in this process, my belief - and my prayer - is that a better leadership will emerge from among their ranks even on the broader social scale to transform our society. With more social investment along the way, the process will be accelerated but even without such investment, I hope our graduates will lead the society in a better way. That’s a promise. They may take time, but DELIVER THEY WILL.”
I thought these exchanges of ideas might give some insight into why leadership is going through such a labor pain in our society and what is the hope for its birth in future. 
(I thank Caron Dhoju and Saroj Dhakal for their perceptive questions and Priyanka Malla and Abhishek Adhikary for reinforcing my belief that KU graduates will deliver better leadership as their times come).

Saturday, May 26, 2012

Current Crisis and Fundamentals to Address Them


Indications as they are emerging around us at this difficult period in our history are ominous, but my best guess is the situation will perhaps not go that far from where a comeback will not be possible.  Honestly speaking, this is both my prayer and optimistic speculation based on the analysis of history.  If we closely look at it, history is in our favor.  Our society, always a mosaic of multi-ethnicity and multi-culturism, has throughout its history never indulged in major inter-ethnic and inter-culture violence, and my best hope is that people of our generations will exercise this wisdom and tolerance inherited as our proud legacy.  

This is not to suggest that there are no problems in the structural design of our society; the problems of exclusion and exploitation are real and they must be corrected through structural adjustments but not at the cost of permanent impairment of social harmony.  If this is what it takes for preserving the nation and its identity, the current leadership in politics should give way to those second or third generation leaders in their outfits who claim they represent the aspiration and interests of those Nepalis who feel they have been excluded and exploited for centuries by the dominant classes in the society.  (By the way, this is what Mahatma Gandhi proposed to Nehru and Patel etc to avoid the colossal blood shading at the time of gaining independence by India – his suggestion was to give leadership to Jinnah who was claiming for a separate state for Muslims, but it was unheeded and the tragic consequence was there for everyone to see and suffer!). 

 This is also not to suggest that good sense always prevails in the heat of emotion that is now being whipped up by certain unscrupulous elements under whatever pretext.  I'd like to believe that the present turmoil we're witnessing is the expression of pent-up feelings and with strong and adjusted leadership (as I suggested before) the nation will find a way forward in a peaceful way with temporary hitches and their inevitable costs.  

Two fundamental facts we must not forget on all sides of the current crisis: a. there will be no existence if there is no co-existence; and b. the loss of Nepali identity is not worth any gain (whatever and however it is being presented).

Monday, May 21, 2012

Lead Like a Leader, Please!


Why common people are plodding along with their work and life in an uninspiring and even undignified way?  Even more important is the issue of ever eager tendency of most of us to be tempted towards easy virtues and unsavory values of life: self-centeredness and selfishness, indiscipline and disorderliness, egoism and vanity, dishonesty and cunningness, deception and manipulation, apathy and insensitiveness, showiness and shallowness,  greed and shamelessness,   obstinacy and aggrandizement, obsessive materialism and short-termism, parochialism and ethnocentrism, cynicism and sarcasm, and self promotion and disrespectful towards other. 

The list could indeed be long but the examples serve the purpose of sampling the basic principles that underlie mainstream practices in the contemporary Nepali society.  They are visibly manifested in the personal, social and professional behaviors of many of us – behaviors that are beneath the decency and dignity of a civilized society.  They make up our psychological profile just as they dominate our behavioral pattern, raising a serious doubt about the prospect of our society transforming into a developed one any time sooner.  Bereft of virtuous values guiding life and work, it's no wonder people are behaving in a way that has reduced existence to a mundane experience and promoted pathological social conditions that we're witnessing all around us.  

Why is there such a social, cultural and psychological deterioration in our society?  I'm sure one can bring in sociological, cultural and psychological perspectives to explain and understand this social phenomenon, which I believe is urgently needed if we are to reverse the process and bring the society back on the rail.  This is a task for academic research and intellectual enquiry, and sooner this is done the better will it be for us all.  Pending this, I wish to add a spiritual dimension to it not so much as a confirmatory analysis but as a tentative explanation worth giving some thought.

My immediate reference is the Bhagavad-gita , a great source of spiritual wisdom in this part of the world - indeed anywhere.  This scripture gives us perhaps the most comprehensive spiritual and philosophical worldview of what life is and what it is for.  In essence it teaches us to perform our prescribed duties with devotional spirit to the supreme authority (read it as supreme cause) and without attachment to results.  Of particular interest in the context of the social degeneracy I've hinted above is the commentary of the Bhagavad-gita on leadership – its role and effect.  Unsure of the worth of fighting his own kinsmen for conquering the kingdom lost through palace conspiracy and unwilling to engage in fratricidal battle the outcome of which would be family devastation, Arjuna dithered, against all expectations, at the battleground of Kuruchhetra unable to perform his duty as the star warrior leading the army of Pandava and ready to lay down his arms.  Lord Krishna reminded him of his prescribed duty not performing which would have far reaching implications much beyond the battlefield of Kuruchhetra into the life of people as they would derive learning by watching their leader perform his duty and behave much the same way:

oBbfr/lt >]i7:tQb]j]t/f] hgM .
; oTk|df0f+ s'?t] nf]s:tbg'jt{t] .. #.@!..


(Whatever action a great man performs, common men follow.  And whatever standards he sets by exemplary acts, all the world pursues - translation by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada)

It's a brilliant comment on the effect of leaders' actions on common people with the suggestion of the prescribed duties of a leader.  Common people follow and imitate leaders, modeling their actions, behaviors and characters as a matter of both fashion and faith without much questioning and analysis.  It's a sociological reality which we have seen throughout the history and in the contemporary life across all domains of society – religion, politics, military, education, development, and business.  Some famous (and infamous) leaders have such a powerful effect that people imitate them almost in the fashion of mass hysteria.  Can this, then, be taken as an explanation of the degenerative social virtues, values, and behaviors?  I contend yes it can be, at least on a broader level.  Leaders' values and behaviors provide an explanatory framework for understanding the pattern of contemporary social values and behaviors hip, though confirmatory studies for conclusive generalization would be required.  

My proposition is that most of our contemporary social values and behaviors that are digressed from civilized and responsible standards of a decent and dignified society are largely a reflection of what leaders are doing (or not doing) and the principles that underlie their actions (or inactions).  Their degenerative virtues, dubious values, and deplorable practices have a mass following just as the Bhagavad-gita taught us.  People have seen leaders being selfish; modeling them, they have started thinking about and serving only their own interests.  Shameless practices of leaders have encouraged people to behave without a moral conscience.  They have become as greedy and manipulative as their leaders.  They have learned parochialism and short-termism by following the footprints of leaders.  Bad examples and wrong role models of the leaders are now in circulation with multiplication by many, many times. 

Effect of behavior modeling on a larger social scale is here for us all to see - and to suffer.  Leaders have created wrong role model for people to learn and adopt.  Higher virtues and principled values are in short supply just as constructive behaviors are, largely because people have few positive leadership role models for them to look upon, have faith on, and follow.  It is the failure of leadership in our society.  Leaders have failed to induce people for positive values and actions, to influence for constructive roles and results, and to inspire for transcending their restrictive present and transforming into new future.  The reason?  Leaders themselves have not personified them.  How can you give something to others if you don't have it with you?  Our society is at the stage where the source is dried up; how can we expect flow downstream?  This is a serious leadership crisis facing our society – the lack of exemplary and authentic leaders for people to model.  

I am aware that one can make arguments – equally compelling – from the opposite end.  It makes some sense to argue that leadership is the reflection of the state of the society and leaders are as good - or as bad - as the people who make them are.  From this perspective, one can even stand in defense of our leaders for what they are (or are not).  My humble submission, though, is that those who lead are leaders; and if our leaders are led by the mass then they are not leaders – they must not be called leaders and must not think they are leaders.  However, we have leaders in every sphere of life, and my focus is on them and the leadership they are exercising.  One cannot help but come to the conclusion that either bad leadership is in circulation in our society or no leadership is in sight.  

Whether we have leadership or not, the fact of the matter is that we have and we are leaders.  But as leaders they are not performing our prescribed duties.  They have deviated and digressed from the path they should be treading; so have common people (as a consequence of the former).  And it's natural for people to lose their direction when the leader is on a derailed course.  Lord Krishna made it clear to Arjuna:  

olb Xox+ g jt]{o+ hft' sd{0otlGb|tM .
dd jTdf{g'jt{Gt] dg'iofM kfy{ ;j{zM ..#.@#..

For if I ever failed to engage in carefully performing prescribed duties, O Parth, certainly all men would follow My path.  (Translation by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada)

And this is what is happening in our society - leaders not engaging in carefully performing prescribed duties and people following their leaders' path by not performing their own prescribed duties.  May be the situation has gone a step further where leaders as well as people are not sure about what their prescribed duties are.  This is a dreadful situation with even more dreadful consequences.  It must be corrected.  The process of change, I believe, must start from leaders themselves for this to have widespread effects in terms of the changes in the virtues, values and behaviors of common people.  Change, like charity, begins at home.  Social change should begin at the top of the social structure.  (The focus and process of such change should be widely discussed, and I'm prepared to share my thoughts for whatever their worth in this dialogue).
The bottom line is leaders leading like leaders. The Bhagavad-gita makes it so clear, doesn't it? 

Saturday, May 19, 2012

Management or Damagement of the Nation?


The art of 'management' has been reduced to the art of 'damagement' in the hands of unscrupulous 'managers' in charge of the nation.  It is both frustrating and pity!

Do the managers of the nation have any clear conceptualization of the' New Order' from the perspectives of the aspirations and potentials of the people and in the context of the emerging future world of which we must be a part of?  It is one thing to indulge in classical rhetoric to keep people engaged in a guessing game for some time, and that's what they are doing.  It is a completely different thing to create and communicate in an inspiring way a credible and convincing picture of the future of the nation, and that's what they are not doing. Without such a 'New Order' on offer, it's not only ridiculous but risky as well to argue for dismantling everything associated with the existing order.  My humble submission is that whatever we do must help us manage our nation for better results, not damage the nation leading to worse consequences.

Yes, it’s true that they have brought changes but without showing any evidence of their ability to manage them.  It raises several issues, for example, what changes and for whom?  Mostly, for them, isn’t it?  We’ve seen them having been completely metamorphosized in terms of their styles and standards. Has there been much change in the life of a commoner?  Well, the fact is there for us all to see.  

So, is the change for betterment or for something else? Betterment for self should be the least priority target of any change for change makers, but here we see a case in contrast.  We know what change our change masters make and for whom do they make them.  We are in a unique predicament as far as our position on acknowledging and accepting changes that have taken place in our life time is concerned.  It’s a Hamletian dilemma: To accept or not to accept.  As Shakespeare would say: That’s the question! A very difficult one, I’d add. If the target and the outcome of changes are as doubtful and suspecting as we’ve witnessed in our history, can we call them change?  In any case, if change cannot be managed, then what happens may not be the change at all (as there will be little that we can accept as change).  And whose responsibility is it to manage change any way?  Can change makers abdicate their responsibility for its proper management?
Does training of politicians in management skills help?  It probably does but then I doubt if it is possible in our social and cultural context where politicians perceive themselves - and are also perceived - as masters and where professionals are looked down as 'His Master’s Voice’ or even worse ‘handy tools’.  I’ve one practical experience of this when I was with the Administrative Staff College where we briefly toyed with this idea but it had to be nipped in the bud as there were hardly any takers.  

My reference obviously is the management of our nation by political masters who have proved time and again that they are only masters, not managers. Questions could be asked also about corporate management, which is also not in a proper shape.  I must confess it is really disappointing.  Corporate management cannot - and must not – draw inspiration from political (mis)management and should not model on it.  

By saying this I seem to be yielding to frustrations. Probably a little bit of it but I accept I must not. No one should. But it's not a bad idea to give in to some frustration once in a while on issues as important as this one.  Frustration is a state of emotional arousal; it indicates the extent of our concern. The challenge for me, and for so many of us, is to convert this emotion into energy and action.  Hoping that I’ll be able to garner a little bit of that energy, once in a while I give in to and treat myself with frustrations over the issue of life and society.

A change in the management style and substance – more so in corporate management - is long overdue.  My hope is pinned on management graduates for this kind of change in the character of management, difficult though it is.  Much as difficult and disappointing it is, a management graduate who is trained in professional management should not abandon the mission in the face of non-supportive and undesirable context that (s)he encounters in career and in life.  On the contrary, they must have a will to face it and fight it with the spirit of changing it for better.  This is what is expected of them.  

In my view, managerialization of the society where a nation and its institutions are managed with professional passion, practices, and processes is the next revolution that should take place. We’ve seen plenty of political revolutions but now is the time when we must engineer managerial revolution.  And management graduates must, despite all odds, show and do the best for which they’re trained.

Friday, May 18, 2012

Devotional Spirit beyond Religion


The other day, taking advantage of a break in the hectic work schedule that has annoyingly become my identity, I spent some time in a religious shrine, watching the fervent devotional spirit and passion of people.  Many fleeting thoughts and feelings whizzed past me but one of them lingered for long.  It was about the link between religion and management, or rather the thought about elevating management to a higher plane as an emotion, as a passion.  I wished other dimensions of social life, e.g. management or social work, could whip up as much devotional energy as by religion. The results would be fabulous, wouldn't they? How can we link spiritualism with management, social work or other dimensions of life?

One specific dimension of this issue is making management and social science education more receptive of spiritualism in terms of curriculum design and program delivery.  This requires refocusing educational programs, e.g. MBA, to incorporate spiritual values and principles for producing management and social science graduates who will perform their managerial and professional responsibilities with a sense of higher purpose and a set of value-based practices. They will, I've no doubt, make a huge difference in how organizations are managed and social actions are conducted. We can expect better results from spiritually-inspired management and professional practices. 

My contention or concern, though, is much larger than this - the devotional spirit and energy that religion evokes in people is so great that they go to any extent to observe religious practices willingly. Why, my question is, management or social work or other aspects of social life cannot generate even a fraction of that zeal? Despite different innovative approaches, management, for example, often fail to obtain and retain a high level of commitment of people to their work, as is a common experience of us all.  I think we need to analyze and understand the fundamental influencing property of religion that is so powerful in eliciting almost ecstatic energy and try to build it into other dimensions of social and organizational life for better commitment and inspired performance of people. I've no clue at the moment but feel that we can do some kind of deep reflection and research to find the answer. 

I think future of the organized society depends on how effective we can be in elevating management and other social actions to the level of religion.  Difficult yet desirable, isn't it?

Thursday, May 17, 2012

More Education but Less Educated People


Most people seem to want education but not to be educated!  Desire for degrees is dominant not the adoption of the learned practices and values in conducting life and its business.  This has led to a situation where we have more education but less educated people in society.  This is worrisome. 
Degrees of course have their values from professional and career perspectives; and I, for one, would not devalue educational degrees but my main concern is that we have less 'educated' people with more 'education'.  Here lies the problem with our educational systems.  Instead of promoting passion for knowledge, education has become a fashion of pseudo-knowledge. This has severe implications for the future of society and civilization. What is more alarming is there is little understanding of these implications for our future, even less initiative to address them.

One of the reasons for such devaluation of education is the 'mass production' technology education is adopting; it has taken away the fundamental purpose of education, reducing it to the status of fast moving consumer good.

If one does not develop values and principles, then education has not served its purpose. Rationality and accountability are the qualities that are based on values and principles without which one is rootless.  Our education is largely producing rootless mass of degree holders.

Education demands - and deserves – a serious reflection as well as action, but that's not forthcoming even from within the institutions of education. This is a tragedy, and no wonder it is festering frustration among many of us. This frustration is often manifested in the lack of faith on the value of education such as education does not make much difference when it comes to developing attitudes, knowledge and capacity as well as in achieving success or worth in life.   However, there is no empirical basis for us to believe that it is true.  As any psychologist would vouch, attitudes, knowledge, ideas and capacity are all learned; they are not genetically inherited. Education is what makes us learn them.  But the tragedy is the educational institutions here have failed to help people acquire and use such attitudes, knowledge and capacity that both reflect and promote the best in human beings from the perspective of development of individuals and the society. Embodiment of these qualities and virtues among the people, who then can be described as 'educated', is the basic purpose of education. Our education is failing us in producing such 'educated' people.

As I see it, the fundamental role of best educational institutions is to discover empirically validated knowledge by integrating discovery of knowledge (through research in all dimensions) and dissemination of knowledge (through teaching again in all dimensions). They conduct and combine both; that's why they are the best. Here in Nepal we have difficulty finding ready acceptance of this perspective and practice, let alone many examples of this model of education. This explains our sluggish growth as a society. 

Having said this let me humbly submit that not all educational institutions are unaware of the fundamental role of education and educational institutions in the society, though they may be at varying stages of developing a right framework for their operations. Kathmandu University, for example, may be taken as an example, which has a clearly stated goal of developing as a research and residential teaching university, though resource constraint and the prevalent mindset of people and government about higher education have slowed down this process. It is trying to work on the model of integration between research and teaching. 

Another point to note is that profit has been the defining character of most educational institutions, which is deeply cutting the root of education.  But again this paradigm does not define all educational institutions and educationists. There are exceptions to this general rule, and we must appreciate the good work some people are doing; otherwise ours will be a society devoid of any good people.

It's already late to have a wider debate on the issue as one year lost in right education means a generation lost in terms of preparing them for their role in productive role in the society.  My worry is such a debate in the present time will inevitable invite political perspectives and prescriptions which will not help address the issue.  It has proved disastrous, as we have witnessed around us, and the reason is not far to seek.  We have seen the breed of politicians who are fully devoid of knowledge and wisdom - and for this reason they may not be even 'educated' as I believe educated are the ones who have knowledge and wisdom relevant to their fields and also to the society at large. Of course, many of them are educational degree holders but those degrees seem to have added more confidence and cunningness to chase self interests.  They might as well be good examples of 'rootless' leaders, not nourished by values and principles expected of 'educated' people.  

Recognition of this fallacy of contemporary education is the first step toward correcting it. Corrected it must be for a better future. 

Monday, May 14, 2012

'Managementlessness' in Political Perspective and Practice


Governance system has completely dominated the national debate and psyche as politicians and their parties are joggling, rather clumsily, the task of framing constitution. Shouldn't we also debate what kind of management system will deliver the promised and expected results in new Nepal? I'd humbly submit that whatever governance system is in place, it won't deliver if the nation is managed as before.  It's time to wake up and work out; it's already late.  I believe that a serious thought must be given as to how the nation is going to manage the new order that will be in place after the current political and constitutional exercise finds a logical conclusion, whatever it is.

One argument could be that without fixing politics, there is no point in debating about the management dimension of the national political order.  But I would argue that this line of thinking and practice has not paid off well to the Nepali nation. In last 60 years we haven't been able to 'fix' politics in a way that delivers good to the people. Fundamental though politics is, it will be suicidal for us to wrangle about another sixty years juggling about the appropriate political model. In the same period, a number of nations have zoomed sky high in their development with a variety of political structures and even with political experimentation. It is in the very nature of politics to be controversial but that should not stop leaders across the wide spectrum of national life to work on appropriate management systems and economic development models for national prosperity. I'd go to the extent of suggesting that the inability of our politics to do any good is at least partly due to its obsession with power issues only whereas politics elsewhere develop clear perspectives on national management and development issues. To me, ignoring these critical issues or waiting till politics gets settled before they are worked out is a doomed strategy from which we are suffering. Chance is that if we start working on them, even politics will be better.

My contention is about 'managementlessness' (forgive me for this idiosyncratic expression) in the perspectives and practices of politics and governance in our country.  This thinking, which one may contest and even condemn, is based on two fundamental propositions: a. management is pervasive across all human endeavors, including political and governance systems, and b. management creates a rational, or at least a logical, order for systemic performance and results.  

With this basic conceptual perspective, I interpret management more in terms of a generic process that facilitates effective performance of any systems, private business, public affairs, politics included.  In this broad sense, I argue that the present political and constitutional debate in Nepal is painfully limited to the issues of governance system, state restructuring and social inclusion without considering their management implications and completely ignoring how will they be managed once they are in place.  This suggests a conventional and unprofessional approach to managing national affairs that has dominated the field in many parts of the world, more so in our country.  And this is what I call 'managementlessness' in our politics, government and society – and perhaps in our national psyche.  

I have difficulty accepting the logic that we must first workout political structures and public institutions before we need to worry about managing them.  I don't agree with this order of priorities that political traditionalism would argue.  They have to be taken up and worked out in tandem so as to ensure the viability and functionality of political systems.  But, unfortunately, our politics and politicians are mostly obsessed with power issue as reflected in the debates of governance or restructuring without even an iota of thinking about management vision in the whole exercise.  I tell anyone who cares to listen that it's gonna be costly for the nation as the new order of things they agree and put in place, if they do it at all, will produce little results relative to the aspirations of the people.  It will be old wine in a new bottle.  Here lies the fallacy and even folly of the entire exercise.  

For this reason, I'm saying that even politicians should have a managerial perspective, of course informed by the complications and complexities of the given social situation, to be able to create and put in place policies, systems and structures that ensure the delivery of peoples' expectations as reflected in the interests of their constituencies.  Here, I am not suggesting that they should be managers or administrators of a particular system or function, but being broadly guided by managerial perspectives as they articulate, represent and work for peoples' interests is, in my humble view, a necessity in the democratic polity in the contemporary world.  I'd not give much weight to the politicians 'own interests' in this debate, if for nothing else then for the simple reason that we have seen too much of it in the past.  The less such interest is present in politics, the better it will be.  

But how likely is it for our politics and politicians to avoid the 'managementlessness' I mentioned above and embrace a 'managerial' perspective at this time when they are engaged, or so they claim, in crafting the blueprint for a new Nepal.  I don't want to be a big pessimist but I see not much hope.  The change is possible when political leadership is able to garner trust and enthusiasm of people, which depends on their credible behavior.  Trust and enthusiasm are unfortunately in short supply in Nepali society, and it is largely the making of politicians themselves. They have failed to be credible.  In fact, my argument is that when leaders fail in politics of credibility they indulge in politics of identity. That too, their own not that of the nation.  And that's exactly what they are doing.  

The politics as we're experiencing – or rather suffering - today is symptomatic of a sick system which must be cured for a healthy future. Cracks in the social system and national identity are already visible to the great pain for most of us. I believe initiatives from the enlightened segments of the society are urgently needed to prevent the nation from crashing down, keeping the professional, disciplinary and psychological differences among us away for this larger cause.
What is sure is the nation's identity is not high on agenda just as management of the nation is not. Personal or group identity seems to be gaining upper ground; this is a sinister motive with colossal consequences. 

Whose fault is this? Are only politicians to blame for the mess we are in now?  What about the roles of intellectuals, elites and professionals?  In a way, we all are responsible for where we are today - but some are more responsible than others.  What is sure is political leadership has failed us.  But so has leadership elsewhere.  The basic question is that of the intellectual foundation and values of Nepali leadership which has never been nourished with enlightened social orientation. It has been trained in the tradition of parochial and self-serving motive and behaviors. 

I'm not sure if the situation could have been avoided with different role behaviors of intellectuals, elites and social leaders. My own analysis is that a different role behavior was - and is - not possible with such a poor tradition of intellectualism, enlightened elitism and sincerity in our social landscape. With scarcity of these fundamental ingredients, I'd be surprised if Nepali society could have behaved differently! Now the challenge is how to construct this foundation before expecting a difference.  And this is where our politics and indeed other dimensions of national life would do well to debate in earnest what kind of management philosophy, systems and structures are required as the nation is grappling with its political and constitutional character and structure.  This will be immensely helped by integrating management into political perspectives and processes.  Managementlessness is costly.