Monday, July 23, 2012

Face of Political Leadership: A Theory-based Analysis

I draw out below some quick inferences from the analysis of the emergence and effectiveness of political leadership based on case studies of some real time politicians in Nepal done by the School’s EMBA participants as part of their Leadership and Change Management course I’m teaching this term.  .  In doing so, I’ve made theory-based meta-analysis of the findings of the target leaders covered in the case studies and tried to identify a few implications for leadership emergence and effectiveness.   
Theory-based Inferences

  • Possession of certain ‘situationally appropriate’ personal traits and their ‘exploitative utilization’ explains their emergence as political leaders.

  • Their effectiveness as leaders is generally low and, in majority cases, is fast declining – their ‘emergence traits’ are not helping much to ensure ‘effectiveness’.  ‘Effectiveness traits’ are in short supply or even completely missing.

  • Low or no observed effectiveness is partly a result of the process of ‘leadership derailment’ the process of which has already set in and is clearly visible in majority cases as one can establish by looking at the behavioral and situational characteristics associated with political leaders.

  • Charisma explains leadership emergence in Nepali politics but fails to account for leadership effectiveness the reason for which appears to be the availability of - and obsession with - ‘personalized charisma’ among political leaders but lack of ‘socialized charisma’ associated with most of them as a result of which they are not able to pursue larger social mission in mobilizing and inspiring large number of people for social movement and actions.
 
  • Some isolated cases suggest traces of ‘inspirational and socialized charisma’ but it is too little to have substantial and visible impact on the life of the nation. Such leaders are not in ‘position’ and ‘power’ to make much difference, and considering the fact that ‘position power’ is the main source of both perceived power and used power in our society, they have little clout for making changes.  Within their own parties they are ‘marginalized’ and they don’t have mass following.  Charisma coupled with power often results in major social transformation, but there is no such convergence here.  Even these leaders don’t have a strong ‘moral power’ base; hence their socialized charisma has produced little result.  This explains low leadership effectiveness of these leaders.

  • The reason why despite little demonstrated leadership effectiveness many political leaders hold attention of people (positively or negatively) can be explained in psycho-dynamic terms.  They have a personality characteristic of a ‘marketer’, who has a high level of adaptability, self-promotability, and aligning capability. 
  • High expectations of people from some political leaders at one stage of their political career can be explained in terms of the personality characteristic of a ‘productive narcissist’, who is a self-centered visionary with a high desire for self-admiration. As they have embodied more of the weak characteristics of a productive narcissist such as little social connectedness and high self-importance rather than the strengths, they have failed to translate their self-generated or text-book vision into social results.  


  • Analysis of personality structures of political leaders indicate the presence of  a little ‘Rebel Child’ ego state among some of them that pushes them from time to time to revolt, break out and challenge the establishment and status quo, and for this reasons their actions are noted by people and they are admired.  However, this is not symbiotically linked with the ‘Adult’ (rational part of personality embodying thoughts and determination) and ‘Natural Child’ (emotional part of personality fueled with energy, zeal and novelty) ego states, which explains why the energy, risk-taking and change-orientation properties of their personality are largely under-utilized without producing profound changes.  It is a case of wasted potential.  


  • There are heavy dose of ‘Critical Parent’ ego state in the personality of many political leaders that explains their ‘authoritarian supremacy’ mindset and behaviors.   


  • Interestingly, even those political leaders who were academic high performers during their student life have not evolved into thought leaders and are not able to lead by creative and appealing ideas and communicating them in way that make them personally meaningful to the mass.  Thought leadership is not a defining characteristic of our contemporary political leadership.  So is authentic leadership; political leaders have not been able to establish themselves authentically as pro-people leaders earning their complete faith, admiration, hope and presenting role models.   


  • In behavioral terms, the styles with which political leaders relate themselves with the led are not in step with the development and responsiveness levels of the various categories of people.  Most groups of people have moved along their consciousness continuum, the political leaders have not.  There is an obsession with old authoritative and directive styles with little evidence of supportive, participatory and achievement-oriented behaviors.  Quality of relationship with people, except with a limited group of the leader’s coterie, is generally low.  There is little evidence that suggests political leaders behave in a way that helps people set goals for themselves and remove obstacles on their way to the goals; on the contrary, leaders may have, knowingly or unknowingly, created more obstacles.    

    
  • Some success examples of a few leaders at some stages of their political career suggest their capability to lead a narrow functional domain or campaign or movement for a certain period of time.  The successful functional leadership is not, however, positively correlated with their success as a general or overall leader.  Availability of ‘general leadership’ is even more in short supply in our politics.  This substantiates the proposition of ‘leadership deficit’ in our society.

Implications for Leadership Emergence and Effectiveness

  • Our society will continue to experience a paradoxical situation of ‘abundance of leaders’ with ‘leadership deficit’ in politics – and by extension in other fields of national life.  Emergence of leaders is made easy by the rather generous supply of certain personal traits that are quickly acknowledged by political parties as essentials for recognizing and rewarding individuals as leaders.  What is needed is to develop better understanding of – and greater recognition for – effectiveness traits as evaluation criteria for making leaders.
  • We will see more derailed leaders in politics, creating further erosion in people’s faith in leadership and dilution of and deviations from the national goals.  ‘Personalized charisma’ will continue to be main currency in politics and the roles of politicians will be either that of a ‘marketer’ or one of ‘weak productive narcissist’.  Psychological makeup of political leaders seems to provide more explanation to the low observed and demonstrated effectiveness of political leaders rather than the situational factors which, if not fully supportive, are not unmanageably adverse either, for the exercise of effective political leadership.   It would be immensely interesting and useful to psycho-dynamically analyze and understand political leaders and how their psychological strengths and deficiencies are affecting the way they are exercising leadership. Research studies would be required for this purpose.  


  • Both dysfunctional mind-sets and behaviors of political leaders as outlined above are not likely to change any sooner, and they will continue to spoil leadership effectiveness in politics.  The socialized charisma, though weak in potency, of some youth leaders will attract more similar youth into politics but as they will have little clout to influence major change, they will abandon the field and take up other vocations for living or will adopt the mainstream style of leadership for personal growth within the party structure.  This will further fuel people’s disappointment and disenchantment with political leaders.  


  • Leaders will continue to emerge without emergence of leadership and with little leadership effectiveness in sight.   Leadership development will be required to correct this situation for which the nation needs to make huge social investment over a period of time in terms of changing social values and norms associated with leadership, creating institutions and role models for training, developing and mentoring leaders, and establishing regulatory and normative frameworks for evaluating and rewarding leaders based on performance.  Leadership, in politics as much as in any other field, just doesn’t happen; the society has to make it.  We cannot wait till the social situation deteriorates so much that a new avatar appears to provide the leadership we need.
  • The most critical implication of the quick analysis is that ‘replacement’ of current set of political leaders will have to be the priority agenda of the nation for the time being.  In the long run, there is no option but to engage in leadership making.

(I acknowledge the efforts of the KUSOM’s EMBA 2011 -12batch for their ground work and initial analysis of political leaders based on which this quick inferences and implications have been drawn.)

Friday, July 20, 2012

Hope of Leadership amidst Hopelessness

Sharing my observation on the current status of leadership (or rather lack of it) in our society, I wrote in my FB status:
“Leaders, leaders and leaders everywhere...but not an inspiration to draw from!  Yes, there is leadership deficit.”
I was asked about what might be the cause of leadership deficit.  To which my reply:
“I appreciate your question the answer to which probably justifies writing a whole book. In essence, I believe our society and our organizations have not invested enough in developing leadership in our country. Leadership, unlike so-called 'leaders' of different shades and colors, does not grow out of nothing; it is the result of huge social and organizational investment, which has not been made on the scale that produces transformational, authentic and intentional leadership with the capability of making substantial changes. That said, I'd promptly add that the social and organizational conditions are, though, ripe for the emergence of high quality leadership. Our society needs to make more investment in leadership making.”
A comment was made that this probably reflects the failure in our education system, suggesting that Kathmandu University in particular has failed to produce leaders despite its reputation.  My humble submission:
“Yes, our education system is partially to blame for having failed to produce leadership in society that inspires and transforms people but leadership development in the society is a function of huge social investment.  Leadership deficit we are experiencing is the result of this lack of social investment. If Oxford or Harvard or any other universities have produced finest leadership in their societies and elsewhere, it’s not only because of the education they give in the universities but more significantly they enjoy the advantage in the societies they are embedded in of having the tradition of huge social investment in making leadership.

“I was referring in my status to the leadership on the larger social scale, and not to the functional leadership that lead people and systems towards making and meeting goals. As for functional leadership in the domains that KU specializes, my own assessment is that our graduates are showing tremendous potential for leading their respective domains in a way that has never happened in our organizations; and indeed they are already exercising quality leadership at the middle to just-below-the top levels. It is there for anyone to see.
“As for the leadership on a broader social and national context, one university, even with KU’s reputation and resolve, cannot shape leadership on its own, no matter how much we try, unless there is huge social investment for it. I’m not sure whether such an investment is forthcoming or not in future, but even if it does, development of the quality leadership on a broader social scale will take time. Two decades is not an adequate time frame for any university to produce social leadership, particularly in the absence of the kind of investment I talked about earlier.  KU’s first few batches of graduates have just entered their mid-career and mid-life.

“Watch it out, when they and their juniors get past this stage, they will definitely take charge of and change the systems they are responsible for in a way never before done. And in this process, my belief - and my prayer - is that a better leadership will emerge from among their ranks even on the broader social scale to transform our society. With more social investment along the way, the process will be accelerated but even without such investment, I hope our graduates will lead the society in a better way. That’s a promise. They may take time, but DELIVER THEY WILL.”
I thought these exchanges of ideas might give some insight into why leadership is going through such a labor pain in our society and what is the hope for its birth in future. 
(I thank Caron Dhoju and Saroj Dhakal for their perceptive questions and Priyanka Malla and Abhishek Adhikary for reinforcing my belief that KU graduates will deliver better leadership as their times come).