Thursday, December 17, 2015

Post- Crisis Blues

At the time of major national crises, we have been witnessing two regular trends - almost always.  The first one is the emergence of inevitable tidal wave of “nationalism”, which is good to see happening (even though it recedes as fast as it rises, true to the nature of a tide!).  The other one is much stronger and long enduring avalanche of “prolific profiteerism” that hits most of us harder than the crisis itself and washes away much of what we try to preserve after the trauma (again as avalanche faithfully does!). 
What is surprising is the scale of both enterprises.  There is always wider participation in them from multiple sections of the society, and surely there is always the much stretched “creative ingenuity” that is visible in their design and delivery. One would not expect the magnitude, intensity and novelty with which they emerge in the immediate aftermath of catastrophes that interrupt the rhythm of life and often threaten life itself.  But they do emerge and exceed expectations (or fears).   
Similarities between them, though, end here.  If the “nationalism” helps little except perhaps some feel-good effect, it does not harm much either.  I have little problem with it, though I wish our emotional arousal at such times resulted in a slightly more productive actions from each one of us contributing to the nation in whose name we go on our psychedelic rampage.  I also wish it did not ebb out so quickly!  It is in the very nature of a psychological escape route that it changes little of the reality but it does not make it worse either.  Our nationalism is our psychological coping mechanism, an instrument that helps us redeem from collective guilt conscience.  To that extent, I welcome the eruption of ‘in-crisis nationalism’.
I cannot, though, say the same about the other ‘inevitable’ of crisis that wrecks life and makes it wretched. It works with a wicked design, even worse than the crisis itself.  Profiteerism perfects its art in our land at the time of national crisis, as we are witnessing now and as we did not so long ago. This indeed happens with almost religious rituality -and regularity! 
What is happening now is no exception, or perhaps a better (or rather bitter?) version of the regularity.  When a large number of people are reeling under acute scarcity of life-sustaining materials and over-supply of political bullyism along and across the border, the usual - and not-so-usual - “profit-multiplying” enterprises have sprung up more swiftly and severely than the onslaught of the crisis.  One is astounded as much by the intensity of this entrepreneurial zeal as by the extension of its scope.  It seems profiteerism is currently the most inclusive ideology and instrument allowing wider partnership and engagement of diverse individuals and institutions across regions, communities, religions, cultures, social hierarchies, and intellectual labels.  A model of “successful inclusion” indeed!  Diversity of shapes and sizes of the actors, but the unity of purpose! The single motivation is making money out of misery.  Misery of millions but Millions for few! 
I would have almost inclined to forget, if not forgive, this ‘evil enterprise’, consoling myself, though painfully, that it is the extreme extension of greed psychology some people always give in to, if it was not for the absolute absence of shame in running it.  The art of shamelessness – and meanness - has perfected in their acts.  No moral qualms whatsoever, no guilt feeling however little, and not even a faded trace of apologetic attitude!  The money machine and the mean motivation are on a long over-drive without any feeling of repent or regret but, on the contrary, with a sense of rightful action.  This is seriously objectionable.  Right to reject others’ rights is as much preposterous in its logic as it is dangerous.  And we know history has always been darkened when some people did exercise their rights to reject the rights of others.  And this is exactly what we are witnessing in full version.  Many, many rights of many, many people are being wrongly - and wrongfully - written off.  No one has this right; no one should have.
In its proliferation drive, profiteerism has grown out of its individual enterprise status into a state of institutionalized ideology.  It has always been there in some way but what we have seen lately is an unprecedented upsurge of the psychology and the corresponding practices of private gain at the cost of public pain by those who are there to protect people from such wicked designs.  A case of the protector being a perpetrator himself!  Indulgence in insatiable greed by public institutions, particularly at the time of crises, is an evidence of how much frail is our society in its constitution and how much uncivilized are we in our conducts. This is a risk from within, and this is a proof of social shallowness and hollowness. Borrowing from V. S. Naipaul, I would say ours is a “wounded civilization”. How else one can explain the gleeful gratification by one member of society in sucking the blood of another fellow sharing the same fate down to the last drop in the name of profit, be it economic, social, political or psychological?         
And the mother of all wonders is our meek-to-enthusiastic participation in profiteerism by letting its entrepreneurs exploit us to their capacity and inclination.  It takes place under various pretexts – from necessity to compulsion, and from optionlessness to helplessness.  We are prepared to pay the highest price, even beyond our means, but not to accept even the lowest pain by avoiding the consumption of the “merchandises” of profiteers.  By not being prepared for suffering a little – or even a lot, if it comes to that – with less than what we are used to in our consumption of the merchandises in the profit-multiplying markets at the time of crisis, we are becoming good partners of bad profiteerism.  And this way we are giving legitimization to it. 
I am not talking here about those among us who see their “social power and prestige” multiplied many times over and think their “psychological aggrandizement” is infinitely intensified by showing their “purchasing power and prowess” in becoming more than willing consumers and the highest bidders of in the market of profiteerism.  To me, this is sheer vulgarism and third-degree vanity but, for reasons I cannot understand let alone explain, they perceive it as their verve or even virtue.  May God bless their lost souls!  But even most commoners like us fall prey to this temptation of giving in to the profiteers’ ill-designs but not to give up our consumption.  Unless we are prepared to suffer a little now we will continue suffering a lot for ever.  Sooner we understand this reality, the better off we will be.     

A crisis shakes us all; it is in its very nature. But it becomes worse when a crisis also brings out the worst in us.  It is a painful irony.  One would naturally expect that we garner our best at these times of troubles but some or many of us seem to give our worst.  In-crisis nationalism diverts us from facing the real issue, and proliferated profiteerism makes the real issue really bad rendering life to more miseries than by the crisis itself.  We would do well to understand them for their worth (or rather lack of it!) and find alternative psychological and practical approaches to coping with post-crisis situation.  A crisis always inflicts wound to us all, like it has done recently, but let us not make ourselves a “wounded civilization” by our own post-crisis actions.      

Wednesday, June 3, 2015

From Euphoric Volunteerism to Prolific Activism: Way Forward for Youth in Action


A silver lining in the current crisis is the way our youth responded.  Shaking of the earth shook them off the inertia.  We saw, almost in a pleasantly surprising way, thousands of them spontaneously engaged with community, rushing to rescue the endangered and reaching out to help the helpless.  Mobilizing resources and giving to the community have gained sudden premium among the youth who otherwise seemed ‘virtually’ locked into self-centrism.  Kudos to those unnamed youth in thousands who have not only rescued the dangerously exposed fellow human beings but in the process have also salvaged our sinking hope about the future of this nation.  Their acts have been both inspired and inspiring. 
Now as the dust of devastation is slowly settling down - hopefully, that is – it is time we reflected seriously about promises and pitfalls arising out of the emergence of the ‘youth action’.  I am sure spontaneous volunteerism is here to stay in both action and attitude of our youth.  So will the desire to reach out, mobilize, and give to the badly bruised.   A new character of our youth and a new youth culture might as well be in the making.  On a broader social level, it will be both a transformation and transformative if it continues and is consolidated.   Will it?  Will we?  I wish the answer was straightforward and unconditional positive.
My worst fear is the phenomenon we are witnessing - and much appreciating - may finally settle into only a euphoric volunteerism the example of which is not that rare for us to recall.  Our culture promotes euphoric emotionality, and the psychology of youth is more susceptible to it.  The risk is this surge of energy and enthusiasm may only be a fad and recede into oblivion for want of a sense of purpose and passion.  Similarly the actions of ‘rushing to help’ may breed among the ‘helpers’ a psychology of giver and savior, reinforcing the traditional pattern of power relationship between the dole dispenser and the resource receiver. 
For avoiding these pitfalls, leadership is critical.  It is also a constraint at the moment.  There seems to be an obvious case of leadership deficit in the sense of the youth not being provided with a purposive direction, role model, elevation of personal standards, and empowerment in their engagement with the community.  I will not be surprised if this has given rise to a perspective of short-termism, not seeing the problems of the communities and their own roles in relation to the needs of the people at distress from a long term consideration.   But an even more important dimension of the leadership in this case is its emergence within and from the youth in action.  Is it evolving?  I wish I could answer positively and confidently. 
Whether it comes from the existing or the emergent leadership, what is important is the recognition and acceptance of the need for regeneration of communities ravaged by the fury of nature, not simply relief, rehabilitation or rebuilding.  While they must be priorities for now, a longer term perspective of regenerating communities for them to rise to a new level of collective being and doing must guide the immediate actions directed towards them.  And the pattern of such actions should be in the form of active and collaborative engagement with the communities, the purpose not being to ‘give’ them but to work with and enable them.  In the long run, the communities should be able to develop and regenerate in line with their own tradition and along the way of their informed aspiration.  External supportive interventions should facilitate, not replace, it. 
Our youth, so active now in working with the communities at distress, will do well to recognize and realize the true nature of their work.  There is a need for moving away from euphoric volunteerism and into the realm of prolific activism as they engage with the communities at the time of distress and even otherwise.  What is needed is not only action but conviction and passion and a clear sense of purpose, both personally and collectively.  My hope is our youth will set this course for themselves and walk the way without waiting for wise words from elsewhere.  
The recent earthquakes have regrettably demolished much of what were dear to us.  If the tradition of our way of working for and with the communities is also abolished in the aftermath of the terrifying tremors, there will be at least one thing for us not to be sad about the loss we have suffered.  This is both a challenge and a choice for our youth.



Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Some Thoughts on the Elections Results and Reactions

I, for one, never take the elections - or for that matter anything else in life and its paraphernalia - lightly (even though I may be a light- weight person – and it doesn't perturb me in any way for being perceived as one!) It pains me, though, to see the 'heavyweights' of politics to act lightly with the mandate they receive through the elections and towards their responsibility for the people who elect them. 


When history gives us opportunity, we must seize it and deliver the promised change in spite of (not in absence of) constraints and challenges. That is leadership and that is revolution as I understand them. One who lets it slip away will have only regret not respect. Counting the sacrifices people made for change and correction in the historical mistakes of the nation and its institutional structures of inequalities and exploitation is not sufficient for a revolutionary - it is indeed an insult to their altruism.


Delivering the promise for which people sacrificed their life and suffered all their life is necessary. And a revolution is not a rent –seeking enterprise; if it is made to be one, it is ILLUSION. I hope our leaders of all shades and colors will reflect on the evolving reality of our time and rise up to the expectations. Comeback for those who have been pushed back is possible if they do it, and those who staged their comeback will be pushed back if they fail to do it. This is the privilege of the sovereign people and it must be respected. 


I believe change makers, whoever they are, must act while taking a long term perspective, and one win - and one loss - is not the time frame for the completion of the mission and take rest. 

Monday, December 9, 2013

Rules of Rule

We must understand what underlie the rule (its principles and purposes) and what are expected of those who are concerned with the rule (conducts and characters of who frame and follow it). A rule without a firm grounding in larger purpose and backed up by proven principles is a restrictive instrument. Failing to see such a larger purpose and proven principle does not turn a rule into a restriction. Not only rules, but even purposes and principles outlive their utility in the evolution of society and its institutions, and hence demand changes.

And everything is not, and must not be, captured by rules; many aspects of human enterprises exist and operate without explicit rules. Self rules or higher level guiding principles are the best way of conducting ourselves in the world; the extent to which we engage in such existential conducts reflects the level of our maturity and development.


Let’s not be ruled by rules and also overrule the rules as most of us are in the process of attaining that maturity. That’s why my plea is to take the rules as responsibilities and creatively use them for our own and others’ betterment. As we make progress in our own development, we should rely more on our own rules and self principles.

Friday, December 6, 2013

Actions Within Constraints and Action Against Constraints

I keep hearing good arguments and at times even good attitudes.  What is more important, though, is an equally good action that translates such inclination into our regular habits and conducts. But, unfortunately, this is not so much visible and this is not what many of us are doing, and it exposes duality in our cultural character.
It’s not that people are not honestly doing what they can from their side to change the nation; many are doing just that but with such a limited impact even after persistent efforts over a long period time. We must understand this limitation of individual honest efforts.
‘What we can do’ is very limited in our society due to severe capacity constraints and the business of ‘managing our requirements’ has limited many of us to a very narrow boundary of self interests. This is where ‘good politics’ is sorely missed in our society as manifested in the ability of politics and politicians to create an enabling environment and inspiration for people to develop their capacity and energy while directing their positive energy and potential to building our nation.
I’ve been trying whole my life to do whatever little I can, just as many others, but who knows better than I do how politics - bad politics, that is –frustrate, not facilitate, such efforts to do and deliver more and tap the potential we have, manifesting itself under various guises. Hence this anger against politics in the society. Having said this, I accept that we must not give up; on the contrary, we must keep going on but not without knowing the reality of the failure of politics and the need for changing it. 

Bureaucracy, Change to Change

By not changing, and more importantly, by not showing willingness and preparedness to change, bureaucracy is holding back other sectors from changing in the right direction and contributing to the loss of future.

An organ of the society which should be showing direction to others and facilitating others movement is itself being directionless and motionless. 

Bureaucracy has difficulty reaching out to and responding to the sections of the society which may help it out of self-imposed inertia, let alone working in partnership with them. 

The mindset of exclusiveness, superiority feeling and political blind-followership must change. 

One person cannot change the system and culture, but I believe change starts from one person.  Leaders in bureaucracy, you must change.

Youth Need to Understand Themselves First

To me, searching within self is good enough; if we find, know and understand our inner self, then the life is worthy of worship. 

My experience is that not many of us make this internal journey, seeking to understand ourselves from within, as a result of which we tend to define ourselves and our achievements using externally established standards and criteria. I have a problem with this exclusively external expression of the meaning of life and its worth. 

Knowing from my young friends that people are searching within themselves and changing for betterment is a melody to my ear. This is what I expect from this generation. At the twilight of life, my dream is to leave behind if not a better world then better people who can make this world better through self betterment.