Saturday, May 19, 2012

Management or Damagement of the Nation?


The art of 'management' has been reduced to the art of 'damagement' in the hands of unscrupulous 'managers' in charge of the nation.  It is both frustrating and pity!

Do the managers of the nation have any clear conceptualization of the' New Order' from the perspectives of the aspirations and potentials of the people and in the context of the emerging future world of which we must be a part of?  It is one thing to indulge in classical rhetoric to keep people engaged in a guessing game for some time, and that's what they are doing.  It is a completely different thing to create and communicate in an inspiring way a credible and convincing picture of the future of the nation, and that's what they are not doing. Without such a 'New Order' on offer, it's not only ridiculous but risky as well to argue for dismantling everything associated with the existing order.  My humble submission is that whatever we do must help us manage our nation for better results, not damage the nation leading to worse consequences.

Yes, it’s true that they have brought changes but without showing any evidence of their ability to manage them.  It raises several issues, for example, what changes and for whom?  Mostly, for them, isn’t it?  We’ve seen them having been completely metamorphosized in terms of their styles and standards. Has there been much change in the life of a commoner?  Well, the fact is there for us all to see.  

So, is the change for betterment or for something else? Betterment for self should be the least priority target of any change for change makers, but here we see a case in contrast.  We know what change our change masters make and for whom do they make them.  We are in a unique predicament as far as our position on acknowledging and accepting changes that have taken place in our life time is concerned.  It’s a Hamletian dilemma: To accept or not to accept.  As Shakespeare would say: That’s the question! A very difficult one, I’d add. If the target and the outcome of changes are as doubtful and suspecting as we’ve witnessed in our history, can we call them change?  In any case, if change cannot be managed, then what happens may not be the change at all (as there will be little that we can accept as change).  And whose responsibility is it to manage change any way?  Can change makers abdicate their responsibility for its proper management?
Does training of politicians in management skills help?  It probably does but then I doubt if it is possible in our social and cultural context where politicians perceive themselves - and are also perceived - as masters and where professionals are looked down as 'His Master’s Voice’ or even worse ‘handy tools’.  I’ve one practical experience of this when I was with the Administrative Staff College where we briefly toyed with this idea but it had to be nipped in the bud as there were hardly any takers.  

My reference obviously is the management of our nation by political masters who have proved time and again that they are only masters, not managers. Questions could be asked also about corporate management, which is also not in a proper shape.  I must confess it is really disappointing.  Corporate management cannot - and must not – draw inspiration from political (mis)management and should not model on it.  

By saying this I seem to be yielding to frustrations. Probably a little bit of it but I accept I must not. No one should. But it's not a bad idea to give in to some frustration once in a while on issues as important as this one.  Frustration is a state of emotional arousal; it indicates the extent of our concern. The challenge for me, and for so many of us, is to convert this emotion into energy and action.  Hoping that I’ll be able to garner a little bit of that energy, once in a while I give in to and treat myself with frustrations over the issue of life and society.

A change in the management style and substance – more so in corporate management - is long overdue.  My hope is pinned on management graduates for this kind of change in the character of management, difficult though it is.  Much as difficult and disappointing it is, a management graduate who is trained in professional management should not abandon the mission in the face of non-supportive and undesirable context that (s)he encounters in career and in life.  On the contrary, they must have a will to face it and fight it with the spirit of changing it for better.  This is what is expected of them.  

In my view, managerialization of the society where a nation and its institutions are managed with professional passion, practices, and processes is the next revolution that should take place. We’ve seen plenty of political revolutions but now is the time when we must engineer managerial revolution.  And management graduates must, despite all odds, show and do the best for which they’re trained.

1 comment: