Why common people are plodding along with their work
and life in an uninspiring and even undignified way? Even more important is the issue of ever
eager tendency of most of us to be tempted towards easy virtues and unsavory
values of life: self-centeredness and selfishness, indiscipline and
disorderliness, egoism and vanity, dishonesty and cunningness, deception and
manipulation, apathy and insensitiveness, showiness and shallowness, greed and shamelessness, obstinacy and aggrandizement, obsessive
materialism and short-termism, parochialism and ethnocentrism, cynicism and
sarcasm, and self promotion and disrespectful towards other.
The list could indeed be long but the examples serve
the purpose of sampling the basic principles that underlie mainstream practices
in the contemporary Nepali society. They
are visibly manifested in the personal, social and professional behaviors of
many of us – behaviors that are beneath the decency and dignity of a civilized
society. They make up our psychological
profile just as they dominate our behavioral pattern, raising a serious doubt
about the prospect of our society transforming into a developed one any time
sooner. Bereft of virtuous values
guiding life and work, it's no wonder people are behaving in a way that has
reduced existence to a mundane experience and promoted pathological social
conditions that we're witnessing all around us.
Why is there such a social, cultural and
psychological deterioration in our society?
I'm sure one can bring in sociological, cultural and psychological
perspectives to explain and understand this social phenomenon, which I believe
is urgently needed if we are to reverse the process and bring the society back
on the rail. This is a task for academic
research and intellectual enquiry, and sooner this is done the better will it
be for us all. Pending this, I wish to
add a spiritual dimension to it not so much as a confirmatory analysis but as a
tentative explanation worth giving some thought.
My immediate reference is the Bhagavad-gita , a great source of spiritual wisdom in this part of
the world - indeed anywhere. This
scripture gives us perhaps the most comprehensive spiritual and philosophical
worldview of what life is and what it is for.
In essence it teaches us to perform our prescribed duties with
devotional spirit to the supreme authority (read it as supreme cause) and without
attachment to results. Of particular
interest in the context of the social degeneracy I've hinted above is the
commentary of the Bhagavad-gita on
leadership – its role and effect. Unsure
of the worth of fighting his own kinsmen for conquering the kingdom lost
through palace conspiracy and unwilling to engage in fratricidal battle the
outcome of which would be family devastation, Arjuna dithered, against all expectations, at the battleground of Kuruchhetra unable to perform his duty
as the star warrior leading the army of Pandava
and ready to lay down his arms. Lord
Krishna reminded him of his prescribed duty not performing which would have far
reaching implications much beyond the battlefield of Kuruchhetra into the life of people as they would derive learning
by watching their leader perform his duty and behave much the same way:
; oTk|df0f+ s'?t] nf]s:tbg'jt{t] .. #.@!..
(Whatever action a great man performs, common men follow. And whatever standards he sets by exemplary
acts, all the world pursues - translation by His Divine Grace A. C.
Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada)
It's a brilliant comment
on the effect of leaders' actions on common people with the suggestion of the
prescribed duties of a leader. Common
people follow and imitate leaders, modeling their actions, behaviors and
characters as a matter of both fashion and faith without much questioning and
analysis. It's a sociological reality
which we have seen throughout the history and in the contemporary life across
all domains of society – religion, politics, military, education, development,
and business. Some famous (and infamous)
leaders have such a powerful effect that people imitate them almost in the
fashion of mass hysteria. Can this,
then, be taken as an explanation of the degenerative social virtues, values,
and behaviors? I contend yes it can be,
at least on a broader level. Leaders'
values and behaviors provide an explanatory framework for understanding the
pattern of contemporary social values and behaviors hip, though confirmatory
studies for conclusive generalization would be required.
My proposition is that most
of our contemporary social values and behaviors that are digressed from
civilized and responsible standards of a decent and dignified society are
largely a reflection of what leaders are doing (or not doing) and the
principles that underlie their actions (or inactions). Their degenerative virtues, dubious values,
and deplorable practices have a mass following just as the Bhagavad-gita taught us. People
have seen leaders being selfish; modeling them, they have started thinking
about and serving only their own interests.
Shameless practices of leaders have encouraged people to behave without a
moral conscience. They have become as
greedy and manipulative as their leaders.
They have learned parochialism and short-termism by following the
footprints of leaders. Bad examples and
wrong role models of the leaders are now in circulation with multiplication by
many, many times.
Effect of behavior
modeling on a larger social scale is here for us all to see - and to suffer. Leaders have created wrong role model for
people to learn and adopt. Higher
virtues and principled values are in short supply just as constructive
behaviors are, largely because people have few positive leadership role models
for them to look upon, have faith on, and follow. It is the failure of leadership in our
society. Leaders have failed to induce
people for positive values and actions, to influence for constructive roles and
results, and to inspire for transcending their restrictive present and
transforming into new future. The
reason? Leaders themselves have not personified
them. How can you give something to
others if you don't have it with you?
Our society is at the stage where the source is dried up; how can we
expect flow downstream? This is a
serious leadership crisis facing our society – the lack of exemplary and
authentic leaders for people to model.
I am aware that one can
make arguments – equally compelling – from the opposite end. It makes some sense to argue that leadership
is the reflection of the state of the society and leaders are as good - or as bad
- as the people who make them are. From
this perspective, one can even stand in defense of our leaders for what they
are (or are not). My humble submission,
though, is that those who lead are leaders; and if our leaders are led by the mass
then they are not leaders – they must not be called leaders and must not think
they are leaders. However, we have
leaders in every sphere of life, and my focus is on them and the leadership
they are exercising. One cannot help but
come to the conclusion that either bad leadership is in circulation in our
society or no leadership is in sight.
Whether we have
leadership or not, the fact of the matter is that we have and we are
leaders. But as leaders they are not
performing our prescribed duties. They
have deviated and digressed from the path they should be treading; so have
common people (as a consequence of the former). And it's natural for people to lose their
direction when the leader is on a derailed course. Lord Krishna made it clear to Arjuna:
dd jTdf{g'jt{Gt] dg'iofM kfy{ ;j{zM ..#.@#..
For if I ever failed to engage in carefully
performing prescribed duties, O Parth, certainly all men would follow My path. (Translation
by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada)
And this is what is
happening in our society - leaders not engaging in carefully performing prescribed
duties and people following their leaders' path by not performing their own
prescribed duties. May be the situation
has gone a step further where leaders as well as people are not sure about what
their prescribed duties are. This is a
dreadful situation with even more dreadful consequences. It must be corrected. The process of change, I believe, must start
from leaders themselves for this to have widespread effects in terms of the
changes in the virtues, values and behaviors of common people. Change, like charity, begins at home. Social change should begin at the top of the
social structure. (The focus and process
of such change should be widely discussed, and I'm prepared to share my
thoughts for whatever their worth in this dialogue).
The bottom line is
leaders leading like leaders. The Bhagavad-gita
makes it so clear, doesn't it?
No comments:
Post a Comment