Wednesday, November 21, 2012

Learning Agility and Leadership



On the issue of learning agility and leadership, a friend of mine had an interesting curiosity:
“Which way does the causation run?  Top leaders have ‘learning agility’ as an innate quality which then helps them be ‘top leaders’ OR they first become ‘top leaders’ and then show ‘learning agility’?

“If ‘learning agility’ matters, why don't we see university professors or successful entrepreneurs, that is, people who have surely demonstrated ‘learning agility’ in spades becoming ‘top leaders’ in high numbers?”


My take on the issue:

It will be difficult to state causal relationship between learning agility and leadership quality or effectiveness unless a number of experimental research works provide valid evidence to this effect.  I’m afraid I’ve no knowledge of any meta-analytical research on this subject that presents a confirmatory conclusion.  To the best of my knowledge, research work on the construct of learning agility has just begun, and it offers potential value of learning agility for leadership behaviors.  But I’m sure we’ll see in future more research on this construct in behavioral sciences with some plausible explanations of the nature and direction of relationship between leadership and learning agility. 

Theoretically, learning agility as a psychological attribute is a learned cognitive ability and not an ‘innate quality’ in the sense of a gift of nature.  From this point of view, we cannot take it as the only predictor of leadership success.  In the process of transacting in the world in various roles, including those requiring to exercise leadership, individuals learn and develop this ability, of course in varying levels, which then helps, in combination and interactions with several other cognitive, affective and behavioral attributes as well as various situational factors,  in exercising effective leadership.  And, in the process of exercising effective leadership, they enrich in experiential, observational and self-reflective ways learning agility.  I guess it’s an iterative process and these two variables hold a mutually reinforcing, rather than a causal, relationship.  So, trying to find a straightforward explanation of which explains what or which follows what is not going to produce any convincing answer, unless of course supported by robust research.  On the contrary, it will have the effect of trivializing the complexity of the relationship. 

For the same reason, I’ll also argue that it will be simplistic to expect certain groups of professionals (‘professors and successful entrepreneurs’, for example) becoming ‘top leaders’ just on the strength of learning agility, which you have suggested they possess in plenty. Becoming effective leaders is a function of multitude of factors, and just one factor will not have a major influence.  Also, I believe learning agility is not necessarily a privilege of these groups of professionals; we can expect this attribute to be available among people outside these professions too. 

Lastly, I guess some ‘professors and successful entrepreneurs’ have exercised, perhaps against popular expectations, excellent leadership in their own domains, irrespective of whether or not they are considered ‘top leaders’. To me, leader and leadership are not the one and the same thing.

Being curious and being eager to quench this thirst of curiosity are the most admirable human traits, which I consider as being high quality leadership behaviors.  I salute the spirit underlying these behaviors.

No comments:

Post a Comment